Why Creative Writing Matters More Than The Grade It Gets 

17/11/2026

Ask a child to write a story and you will often get one of two reactions: a burst of wild enthusiasm, or a slow slide down the chair. Somewhere along the way, many of them learn that writing is something to be marked rather than enjoyed. The red pen looms, the target grade hovers, and the joy quietly leaks out. 

This is a collaborative post

That is a shame, because the real value of creative writing has very little to do with the number at the top of the page. It teaches children to order their thoughts, to notice the world, and to sit with an idea long enough to shape it into something. Those are skills that outlast any mark scheme. 

Here is a practical way to help children write for the pleasure of it, one step at a time. 

Step one: separate writing from marking 

Before anything else, make it clear that this writing will not be scored. No grade, no corrections, no commentary on spelling. When the pressure to perform disappears, children stop writing what they think an adult wants and start writing what they actually mean. Keep a notebook that is strictly “theirs”, one no teacher or parent will ever grade. 

Step two: start small and specific 

A blank page asking for “a story” is daunting. A blank page asking for “five sentences about the scariest smell in the house” is an invitation. Give a narrow, slightly odd prompt and watch how quickly the resistance melts. Specific beats grand every time. 

Step three: let them write badly on purpose 

Give permission for the first draft to be rubbish. Tell them outright that nobody writes a good first version, including professional authors. Children who know the first attempt is allowed to wobble will take more risks, and risk is where the interesting writing lives. 

Step four: read it aloud 

Once something is on the page, have them read it out. Reading aloud catches clumsy sentences and celebrates the good ones, and it does so without a single correction mark. It also reminds children that writing is meant to be heard by someone, which makes the whole thing feel worthwhile rather than private homework. 

Step five: ask questions, don’t fix 

When you respond, resist the urge to tidy it up. Ask instead: what happened next, why did the character do that, what did it smell like in that room? Curiosity invites the writer back in. Correction shuts them down. The goal is to keep them wanting to add, not to hand back a polished version they no longer recognise. 

Step six: make it a habit, not an event 

Ten minutes a few times a week does more than a marathon session once a term. Little and often builds the muscle, and it keeps writing in the ordinary, low-stakes part of a child’s day rather than the formal, anxious part. 

Why schools are rethinking the grade 

The best educational settings have noticed this too. Rather than treating every piece of writing as something to be assessed, many are carving out space for writing that is simply explored and enjoyed. Schools that value expression alongside academic rigour, such as a senior school with a strong tradition in the arts, tend to produce confident writers precisely because they do not reduce every story to a score. The team at New Hall School has long argued that a child who loves to write will, in time, write well, and the grades usually follow. 

So the next time your child hands you something they have made up, resist the instinct to reach for the marking voice. Ask what happens next instead. The grade will take care of itself. You can read more about this approach at https://newhallschool.co.uk. 

*This article was contributed by the team at New Hall School, a co-educational independent day and boarding school in Essex for pupils aged 1 to 19. Known for its commitment to academic excellence and creative expression within a supportive, values-led community, New Hall School supports young people to develop both the skills and the confidence to find their own voice.* 

How did I do?

Did you enjoy this post? Why not hang around and read a few more whilst you’re here.

If you want to read some more of my usual kind of stuff, head over to my Mum Life section. You’ll find all things parenting with a tongue-in-cheek twist. Or if you want some days out and UK family holiday inspiration, click on the Travel section.

If you like a bit of social media madness, pop over to my Facebook page. You’ll be able to have a laugh at what ridiculousness goes on in my house with three very small boys on a daily basis. Warning – there is often sarcasm, and usually swearing. There are also great travel reviews. Feel free to join my Twins, Tantrums and Cold Coffee – Shits and Giggles Parenting Group too, where everyone shares their hilarious stories.

If you like what you see, how about you check me out on Pinterest, Twitter and Instagram too.

And if you want to work with me, feel free to give me a shout at helen@twinstantrumsandcoldcoffee.com and I’ll get back to you.

Leave a comment